Despite greater enforcement in recent years, Nigeria has persisted as a key export hub for elephant ivory and pangolin scales shipped to Asia, becoming a central node of the illegal wildlife trade from Africa, according to a new report by the Environmental Investigation Agency. While enforcement operations have increased in Lagos, the illegal trade has now relocated to the country’s smaller port cities. Enforcement is still lacking: Of 58 documented wildlife crime incidents in Nigeria since 2021, only six resulted in prosecutions. Across West and Central Africa, the arrest-to-conviction rate is just 16%, with low-level actors often taking the fall while key players avoid justice. At his storefront in Lagos’s sprawling Lekki Craft Market, alongside handwoven raffia baskets and Ankara fabrics, an illegal wildlife trader, identified only as Mr. X, sells an array of carved ivory products. It’s from this shop that he established links with buyers across Asia, sending out large volumes of wildlife products sourced from the forests of Gabon, Cameroon, and the Central African Republic. In early 2022, Mr. X was arrested for unlawful possession of nearly 900 kilograms (nearly 2,000 pounds) of pangolin scales and 145 kg (320 lb) of elephant ivory. His operations ceased, and in May 2023, he was convicted and sentenced to two years in prison. But within months, Mr. X was free. Some 18 months later, investigators found that he was once again offering up pangolin scales for sale. Business had rebounded. Investigators found that Mr. X had likely spent only a few months in custody and reportedly paid several million naira, the equivalent of a few thousand U.S. dollars, in bribes through his lawyer during court proceedings. The saga of Mr. X is emblematic of the ongoing corruption and persistence of West and Central Africa’s illegal wildlife trade that’s pushing many species to the brink, despite better enforcement in recent years, according to a new report by the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA), an international NGO that digs into environmental crimes across the world. Criminal networks, investigators found, have continued to evolve and evade efforts to clamp down on the flow of products derived from imperiled wildlife. “On the one hand, there’s been progress. Nigeria has had its first prosecutions … Even five years ago, it had not had any on wildlife trafficking at that level,” said Justin Gosling, who leads EIA’s program on securing criminal justice. “But there are competing crime interests and priorities in [African] countries. Even with the best intentions of tackling wildlife crime, we have all sorts of other issues, he said, noting that there could have been more progress. “But [these] countries have been blighted by the same kind of economical and other issues that have affected us all.”
Wildlife trafficking persists in West, Central Africa despite crackdowns
